Sargent Shriver National Center on Poverty Law

Poverty Scorecard 2011

Senate bills

House bills

Senate vote 219

  • 51 yea
  • nay 49

3/5 Required Tally: 51-49Failed to pass

This vote was on the motion to proceed to consider the Middle Class Tax Cut Act of 2011, S. 1917.[1] The Middle Class Tax Cut Act would have created jobs by providing payroll tax relief for middle class families and businesses.[2]

Specifically, the Act would have:

  • Cut employees and the self-employeds 2012 payroll tax in half, from 6.2% to 3.1%.[3] This cut would have benefitted approximately 160 million workers and put nearly $1,500 into the pockets of the average American family.[4]
  • Cut employer-side payroll taxes in half, from 6.2 to 3.1 percent, for the first $5 million of taxable payroll for 2012.[5] Although this cut would have benefitted all businesses, 98% of businesses would have seen their payroll taxes cut in half.[6]
  • Eliminated the payroll tax paid by employers on the first $12.5 million of the employers increased taxable payroll for the 4th quarter of 2011 and on the first $50 million in increased payroll for 2012.[7] This cut would have given businesses an added incentive to hire new employees.
  • Imposed a 3.25% surtax on modified adjusted gross income in excess of $1 million for single taxpayers and married couples filing jointly.[8] This tax on millionaires would have offset the cost of the bill, thereby enabling Congress to implement the job-creating payroll tax breaks without adding to the national deficit.
  • Protected Social Security, by requiring that the Social Security Trust Fund be made whole through transfers from the General Fund.[9]

The motion to proceed did not receive the 3/5 vote required for passage.[10]

For more information

» Visit govtrack.us
Detailed information about the bill, including full text, floor speeches, sponsors and more

» Toggle footnotes

Legend

= vote to fight poverty = vote against fighting poverty = no vote


Alabama
Shelby, Richard N [Shelby / Alabama Senate #2]Sessions, Jeff N [Sessions / Alabama Senate #1]
Alaska
Murkowski, Lisa N [Murkowski / Alaska Senate #2]Begich, Mark Y [Begich / Alaska Senate #1]
Arizona
Kyl, Jon N [Kyl / Arizona Senate #1]McCain, John N [McCain / Arizona Senate #2]
Arkansas
Boozman, John N [Boozman / Arkansas Senate #1]Pryor, Mark Y [Pryor / Arkansas Senate #2]
California
Feinstein, Dianne Y [Feinstein / California Senate #2]Boxer, Barbara Y [Boxer / California Senate #1]
Colorado
Udall, Mark Y [Udall / Colorado Senate #2]Bennet, Michael Y [Bennet / Colorado Senate #1]
Connecticut
Blumenthal, Richard Y [Blumenthal / Connecticut Senate #1]Lieberman, Joe Y [Lieberman / Connecticut Senate #2]
Delaware
Carper, Tom Y [Carper / Delaware Senate #1]Coons, Christopher Y [Coons / Delaware Senate #2]
Florida
Rubio, Marco N [Rubio / Florida Senate #2]Nelson, Bill Y [Nelson / Florida Senate #1]
Georgia
Isakson, Johnny N [Isakson / Georgia Senate #2]Chambliss, Saxby N [Chambliss / Georgia Senate #1]
Hawaii
Inouye, Daniel Y [Inouye / Hawaii Senate #2]Akaka, Daniel Y [Akaka / Hawaii Senate #1]
Idaho
Risch, James N [Risch / Idaho Senate #2]Crapo, Mike N [Crapo / Idaho Senate #1]
Illinois
Durbin, Dick Y [Durbin / Illinois Senate #1]Kirk, Mark N [Kirk / Illinois Senate #2]
Indiana
Coats, Daniel N [Coats / Indiana Senate #1]Lugar, Dick N [Lugar / Indiana Senate #2]
Iowa
Harkin, Tom Y [Harkin / Iowa Senate #2]Grassley, Chuck N [Grassley / Iowa Senate #1]
Kansas
Roberts, Pat N [Roberts / Kansas Senate #2]Moran, Jerry N [Moran / Kansas Senate #1]
Kentucky
Paul, Rand N [Paul / Kentucky Senate #2]McConnell, Mitch N [McConnell / Kentucky Senate #1]
Louisiana
Vitter, David N [Vitter / Louisiana Senate #2]Landrieu, Mary Y [Landrieu / Louisiana Senate #1]
Maine
Snowe, Olympia N [Snowe / Maine Senate #2]Collins, Susan Y [Collins / Maine Senate #1]
Maryland
Cardin, Ben Y [Cardin / Maryland Senate #1]Mikulski, Barbara Y [Mikulski / Maryland Senate #2]
Massachusetts
Kerry, John Y [Kerry / Massachusetts Senate #2]Brown, Scott N [Brown / Massachusetts Senate #1]
Michigan
Levin, Carl Y [Levin / Michigan Senate #1]Stabenow, Debbie Y [Stabenow / Michigan Senate #2]
Minnesota
Klobuchar, Amy Y [Klobuchar / Minnesota Senate #2]Franken, Al Y [Franken / Minnesota Senate #1]
Mississippi
Cochran, Thad N [Cochran / Mississippi Senate #1]Wicker, Roger N [Wicker / Mississippi Senate #2]
Missouri
Blunt, Roy N [Blunt / Missouri Senate #1]McCaskill, Claire Y [McCaskill / Missouri Senate #2]
Montana
Tester, Jon N [Tester / Montana Senate #2]Baucus, Max Y [Baucus / Montana Senate #1]
Nebraska
Nelson, Ben Y [Nelson / Nebraska Senate #2]Johanns, Mike N [Johanns / Nebraska Senate #1]
Nevada
Reid, Harry Y [Reid / Nevada Senate #2]Heller, Dean N [Heller / Nevada Senate #1]
New Hampshire
Ayotte, Kelly N [Ayotte / New Hampshire Senate #1]Shaheen, Jeanne Y [Shaheen / New Hampshire Senate #2]
New Jersey
Lautenberg, Frank Y [Lautenberg / New Jersey Senate #1]Menendez, Bob Y [Menendez / New Jersey Senate #2]
New Mexico
Bingaman, Jeff Y [Bingaman / New Mexico Senate #1]Udall, Tom Y [Udall / New Mexico Senate #2]
New York
Gillibrand, Kirsten Y [Gillibrand / New York Senate #1]Schumer, Chuck Y [Schumer / New York Senate #2]
North Carolina
Burr, Richard N [Burr / North Carolina Senate #1]Hagan, Kay Y [Hagan / North Carolina Senate #2]
North Dakota
Conrad, Kent Y [Conrad / North Dakota Senate #1]Hoeven, John N [Hoeven / North Dakota Senate #2]
Ohio
Brown, Sherrod Y [Brown / Ohio Senate #1]Portman, Robert N [Portman / Ohio Senate #2]
Oklahoma
Coburn, Tom N [Coburn / Oklahoma Senate #1]Inhofe, Jim N [Inhofe / Oklahoma Senate #2]
Oregon
Merkley, Jeff Y [Merkley / Oregon Senate #1]Wyden, Ron Y [Wyden / Oregon Senate #2]
Pennsylvania
Casey, Bob Y [Casey / Pennsylvania Senate #1]Toomey, Patrick N [Toomey / Pennsylvania Senate #2]
Rhode Island
Reed, Jack Y [Reed / Rhode Island Senate #1]Whitehouse, Sheldon Y [Whitehouse / Rhode Island Senate #2]
South Carolina
DeMint, Jim N [DeMint / South Carolina Senate #1]Graham, Lindsey N [Graham / South Carolina Senate #2]
South Dakota
Johnson, Tim Y [Johnson / South Dakota Senate #1]Thune, John N [Thune / South Dakota Senate #2]
Tennessee
Corker, Bob N [Corker / Tennessee Senate #2]Alexander, Lamar N [Alexander / Tennessee Senate #1]
Texas
Cornyn, John N [Cornyn / Texas Senate #1]Hutchison, Kay Bailey N [Hutchison / Texas Senate #2]
Utah
Lee, Mike N [Lee / Utah Senate #2]Hatch, Orrin N [Hatch / Utah Senate #1]
Vermont
Sanders, Bernie N [Sanders / Vermont Senate #2]Leahy, Patrick Y [Leahy / Vermont Senate #1]
Virginia
Warner, Mark Y [Warner / Virginia Senate #1]Webb, Jim Y [Webb / Virginia Senate #2]
Washington
Cantwell, Maria Y [Cantwell / Washington Senate #1]Murray, Patty Y [Murray / Washington Senate #2]
West Virginia
Manchin III, Joe N [Manchin III / West Virginia Senate #1]Rockefeller, Jay Y [Rockefeller / West Virginia Senate #2]
Wisconsin
Kohl, Herb Y [Kohl / Wisconsin Senate #2]Johnson, Ron N [Johnson / Wisconsin Senate #1]
Wyoming
Enzi, Mike N [Enzi / Wyoming Senate #2]Barrasso, John N [Barrasso / Wyoming Senate #1]

* Members in italics and marked with an asterisk (*) are not ranked.